Vital Football

Latest Blackpool FC News

Villa Fans: Bannan Going Nowhere

Villa Fans: Bannan Going Nowhere

Barry Bannan is going absolutely nowhere, according to a group of Aston Villa supporters.

Following the Blackpool Gazette`s story that the Seasiders were lining up a £1m bid for the Scotland international, we asked Villa fans for their thoughts on potentially losing their young midfielder.

And the results were resoundingly negative from a Pool point of view, with almost all stating that there is no chance that Alex McLeish would let the player leave.

Although still only 21, Bannan is seen as a player for the present after a eye-catching cameo in the 3-1 win against Blackburn Rovers on Saturday.

There was other conjecture about whether the club will try to land Scott Parker and it was noted that Bannan is ahead of Jean Makoun in the pecking order at Villa Park.

Below are a collection of responses we received from Vital Villa. 'Prepared' said: 'The only player available from the midfield is Makoun.. Possibly Ireland.

Bannan is the future here, especially after his cameo on Saturday when he showed how he can dictate the pace of a game and keep it flowing.'

'DeanoVilla':'Seems like he's very much in Big Eck's plans, and currently ahead of Makoun and Ireland in the pecking order, so I doubt there is any legs in this rumour.

Then again, it depends how desperate McLeish is to sign Scott Parker. If he can't offload Ireland or Makoun, and the offer for Bannan is good enough, who knows.

Very slim chance I'd say though.'

'HH2' said: 'Bannan would not release enough wages off the payroll for it to make the Parker deal viable who I am sure will end up at Spurs anyway... Bannan is a work in progress and is certainly a player Villa like and is on low wages in football terms so no I don't see him moving at all.'

'TheFear': 'We don't have a deep enough squad really to allow a young up and coming player to go UNLESS they don't rate him/think his height is an issue.

The fact he played Saturday (as sub) suggests he is very much in the Clubs plans, unless we go for someone like Scott Parker or another centre mid, I can't see us letting him go at all.

Hope not, want to see him get his chance.'

'romanianvillain' said: 'There is no way we will sell him unless it's a very good offer (which it probably won't be). Big Eck is obviously planning on using him on a regular basis this season, and would much prefer to get rid of Makoun who seems to be less in his plans.'

'Nimmo': 'I thought he looked good on Saturday and would have impressed the manager. When he was brought on, he gave us a little injection of attacking intent that was much needed after Blackburn had pulled a goal back.

As others have said above, he seems to be higher in the pecking order than Ireland and Makoun right now.'

One crumb of comfort for Blackpool supporters hoping for a permanent Bannan transfer came from 'Saurat', who said: 'Don't believe this for a minute BUT, were it to prove true, it would be the biggest indication so far that Randy has embarked on asset-stripping the club. Even if we were in for Parker (which I don't think we are, alas) it would make more sense to find buyers for Ireland or Makoun rather than sell an up-and-coming player.

Of course it might be easier to sell Bannan, but he represents our future, were he to go it would send out a terrible message.'

The Blackpool Gazette stated that Ian Holloway could settle for a loan deal, but even that looks unlikely given Bannan's role within the Villa squad at present.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Tuesday August 23 2011
Time: 12:09PM


£1M for Barry Bannan? Dream on! He's a top quality prospect just waiting for a run in the side. No way will Villa sell him any time soon. I think Bannan will be at Villa for another 6-7 years. Far too good for Blackpool. And £1M? Is this some sort of joke? :S Would you like Marc Albrighton for £500k too? lol
23/08/2011 12:48:00
... so thats him away to cit£h next year then for £20.mill astvil?
23/08/2011 13:03:00
Next year? Don't be silly. That's Bent's turn to go for big money. Then the following year it's Delph. Then the next year is N'Zogbia. Then the next year it's going to be Albrighton or Bannan, not sure which one yet lol. Money has ruined football, it's a sad sad day when you realise even clubs as big as Aston Villa, Tottenham and now even Liverpool can't compete with the likes of Man City, United & Chelsea anymore purely because they have far too much money. The Premier League is no longer a fair competition, only 3 teams can win it. Very sad.
23/08/2011 13:06:00
Sad indeed -- It was meant more tongue in cheek, than to bring anyone down, but can see why some of us villans feel that way
23/08/2011 13:10:00
Suppose after offering 2 rabbits and 3 sheaves of wheat last year for Adam this is a little playful payback? Seriously though, this lad is special and if we were to sell him as we sold Cahill etc, then the moans about our ex-bluenose manager would pale compared.
Stourbridge Villan
23/08/2011 17:23:00
1m for barry bannan? HAHAHAHA...If bannan left i would want him to go to a massive club where he can win big things not some half arsed club that have 'never' been famous. Blackpool are and will stay in the championship, bannan is too good for that level, jog on.
24/08/2011 00:08:00
Show some class P.Avfc and button it for once.
24/08/2011 06:29:00
ian holloway can ***** off after his comments last year! domt get me wrong i like there supporters but i hate holloway
24/08/2011 10:04:00
a bid comes in for a villa player .... why suddenly get offended, it would have been rejected immediately if it was that bad. why on earth would he go straight to a big club, hes not even proven at that level. Theres plenty of youngsters in the leagues ahead of him
24/08/2011 13:19:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Frampton Fight Upgraded

Recent Blackpool Articles

Could L1 & L2 Get A Much Needed Cash Boost?

The EFL have crunched the full attendance numbers for the season of 2016/17 and their...

What Is A Club Developed Player & Why Does It Matter

EFL member clubs will be held to a 'club developed player' requirement from the start of the 2018/19 campaign.

A Far Safer Prediction For Blackpool After Recent Form

Recent form has made me like the super-computer far more than I did last month!

League One 2017/18 Golden Boot Battle (1/3/18)

The season might only be a few months old in terms of the calendar, but with high expectations for some players when it comes to this year's Golden Boot battle...

Blackpool Archived Articles

Vital Blackpool articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Blackpool
Write For Vital Blackpool
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

What will the outcome be against Bury
Suggested By:
Blackpool Win42%
Bury Win8%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Blackpool Results (view all)

Blackpool Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

3.premier 182
The Vital Football Members League