UK time is: 07:04:28
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Men In Black: Injustice Watch!

Saturday's defeat away at Southampton, and more potently our disallowed goal, highlighted not only that we're incredibly unlucky at present, but that perhaps we`ve registered our name onto a list of footballing casualties at the hands of the beautiful games rulebook.

As Danny Coid whipped in the cross for Gary Taylor-Fletcher to head home the equaliser for the travelling Seasiders, it appeared that referee Iain Williamson blew his whistle for a foul on the full back, which resulted in a freekick for Blackpool outside the area, which nothing came of. However, the time difference between ball leaving Coidy`s foot and meeting GTF's head was minimal.

Why couldn`t the man in black wait for play to develop before blowing for the foul and giving us the freekick? This is where there is a massive loophole in the rules: 'The referee may 'call back' play and penalise the original offence if the anticipated advantage does not ensue within a short period of time, typically taken to be four to five seconds.' The whole ruling opens itself to personal interpretation, and thus serious confusion and as we saw on Saturday, anguish.

But why couldn't Mr Williamson wait for just five, even four seconds, to blow his whistle? I`m not one for criticsising referees generally, but I don't see why the ref had to blow straight away, and not allow common sense to prevail and wait for play (and a goal!) to develop?

Is it time for FIFA to introduce a new ruling, that doesn`t allow for personal interpretation by refs, ala Rugby? Having watched the World Cup recently, the thing that struck me most (apart from the respect shown to officials) was that advantages were dictated by the players. If, for example, the defending side had committed an offence, the referee would stick his hand up in the air, communicate that an advantage had ensued, and the attackers could then either ask for the penalty (freekick in Football speak of course!) or carry on with their attack as before. An advantage in Rugby also lasts far longer than the guided 'four or five seconds' in Football, and although fully aware that Rugby is a much slower sport than Football, I believe something similar would clearly have its benefits.

Take Saturday as an example, the attack would've carried on, we would`ve scored, the game's at 1-1 and there for the taking at that point. Three points would've taken us 18th, but now we sit in 21st, level on points with QPR, who are in the relegation zone only by goal difference.

As for the overall refereeing performance, our voters on the forum saw him as poor, and gave him an average score of just 1.3, but it begs the question on what ratings he would`ve achieved if the ambiguous advantage rule wasn't so?

Couple Saturday's rating of 1.3 with his prior score of 1.1, which he accumulated in the playoff semi final against Oldham Athletic, Williamson's Men In Black rating stands at 1.2, which obviously sees him languishing in the lower reaches of our table, which stretches to over 30 referees now.

Pos Name
P
Y
R
R
1 K Hill
1
2
0
4.4
2 A D'Urso
2
1
0
3.7
3 A Talyor
1
0
0
3.55
4 G Sutton
1
1
0
3.5
5 C Oliver
1
0
0
3.4
= E Iderton
1
0
0
3.4
7 M Clattenburg
1
2
0
3.36
8 M Russell
1
0
0
3.03
9 M Pike
1
1
0
3
10 C Foy
2
3
0
2.75
11 S Mathieson
1
0
0
2.6
= M Dean
1
0
0
2.6
13 K Wright
1
1
0
2.6
14 A Marriner
2
2
0
2.2
15 A Hall
1
2
0
2.3
16 RJ Lewis
1
1
0
2.25
= R Olivier
2
5
0
2.25
17 K Friend
1
3
0
2.21
18 C Webster
1
1
0
2.1
19 M Heywood
1
0
0
2
20 Mark Halsey
1
0
0
1.9
= N Miller
1
0
0
1.75
22 J Moss
1
1
0
1.72
23 A Penn
1
2
0
1.5
= D Deadman
1
2
0
1.5
= L Probert
1
2
0
1.5
26 G Laws
1
1
0
1.3
27 S Bratt
1
4
0
1.3
28 Mr Thorpe.
1
2
1
1.2
29 I Williamson
2
4
0
1.2
30 G Atkins
2
2
0
1,1
31 T Kettke
1
2
0
1
32 M Jones
1
3
0
1
33 P Talyor
1
2
1
1




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Join the Vital Fantasy Football League - its Free!

The journalist

Writer: Editor Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday November 26 2007

Time: 5:23PM

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

Meet the Referee v Burnley (Thursday April 17 2014)

Leeds Review (Thursday April 17 2014)

Fans display their anger (Thursday April 10 2014)

Relegation Battle Looms (Monday April 7 2014)

Stats: Blackpool v Yeovil (Sunday April 6 2014)

All Square at Loftus Road (Wednesday April 2 2014)

Battling pool earn Priceless Point (Wednesday April 2 2014)

Full time: Blackpool 1-0 Huddersfield (Saturday March 22 2014)

Archived Articles

List All Vital Blackpool Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. premier 1 228
2. Poole-Pool 170
3. Bear1951 132
4. SeasideEssexXile 122
5. Albert Ramsbottom 108
6. SaskPool 103
7. UAE Seasider 75
8. BobHatton 69
9. nodrogaty 48
10. 53CODGER 47

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
17. Huddersfield 42 12 10 20 -9 46
18. Birmingham 41 11 10 20 -10 43
19. Doncaster 42 11 10 21 -26 43
20. Blackpool 42 10 12 20 -26 42
21. Charlton 41 10 11 20 -24 41
22. Millwall 42 9 13 20 -30 40
23. Barnsley 42 9 12 21 -28 39

Breaking League News

Your Vote Counts Vital Latics Player Of The Season
Wigan : 18/04/2014
Early Team News - Latics v Reading
Wigan : 17/04/2014 23:52:00
Huddersfield v Brighton (Preview)
Brighton : 17/04/2014 23:34:00
What The Bosses Say - Latics v Reading
Wigan : 17/04/2014 23:30:00
Performance Of The Century Wanted By Johnson
Yeovil : 17/04/2014 23:24:00
Blackburn Is Huge - Palazuelos
Yeovil : 17/04/2014 23:13:00
Forde Takes Player Of The Year Award
Millwall : 17/04/2014 22:46:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Do you agree with last nights protests?
Suggested By:  
Totally agree 63%
Other ways to show it 37%